The case for & against
Bull & Bear analysis
Bullish
Hagerty, Inc. (NYSE: HGTY) is a leading provider of specialty insurance for classic and collector vehicles, serving a vibrant community of auto enthusiasts. With a growing membership of over 1.9 million, Hagerty leverages its unique underwriting expertise to capture the enthusiastic collector market. The company is positioned at the forefront of the collector car segment, with a focus on expanding its portfolio of insurance offerings and enhancing customer experiences through strategic technology investments. As the collector vehicle market continues to gain momentum, Hagerty's prominence in this niche indicates a robust growth trajectory.
Bull says
- ↑Q2 written premiums up 19% YoY to $425 M.
- ↑Earned premiums +42% to $252 M, driven by new policies.
- ↑Adjusted EBITDA jumped 32% to $160 M in H1 2026.
- ↑Membership grew 279K in H1 to ~2.18 M enthusiasts.
- ↑2026 GAAP net income guidance of $18–30 M; analysts raised forecasts 107%.
- ↑High earnings yield and strong profitability factors support valuation.
Bear says
- ↓Retention rates slipped 50 bp YoY in core book.
- ↓GAAP revenue fell 6% to $667 M in H1 due to Markel accounting.
- ↓Gap revenue down 6%, pressuring H1 profitability.
- ↓Quotes from younger enthusiasts now represent 60% of demand.
- ↓Operational complexity from Markel fronting obscures revenue clarity.
- ↓Elevated leverage and liquidity risks plus weak growth factor.
Earnings Call · Q1 2024 · Mgmt. Guidance
Updated 05-10-2025bullish
Transcript signals
Bull points
- Hagerty may be a leading provider of insurance for collectible vehicles in North America, but insurance does not define us. The love of cars does, and that is the key competitive advantage we have utilized to differentiate our approach and to position us to deliver high rates of compounding profitable growth in the years to come.
- This team of highly engaged car people has never been better aligned around our strategic growth ambitions and is well positioned to deliver great results for stockholders.
- In the first quarter, we delivered 24% growth in total revenue to $272 million, robust new business count and improved retention of 89% compared to 88% in the prior year produced written premium gains of 19%.
Read full transcript analysis ›